Played on Sunday, 20 September 2026, matchday 5 of Premier League, at Etihad Stadium in Manchester, referee R. Jones.
Manchester City 5-3 Sunderland: spectacular show at the Etihad, Semenyo decisive and Brobbey scores hat-trick

The Etihad Stadium hosted a rare spectacle on Sunday afternoon: eight goals, continuous emotions and two men capable of dominating the scene in opposite ways. Enzo Maresca's Manchester City claimed their fifth consecutive Premier League victory with a 5-3 win, but they had to sweat for every single goal against a Sunderland that proved to be far from a supporting cast. The Citizens remain the only team with a perfect record in the league, with 15 points in five matches.
The match ignited from the very first minutes: after just a caution to Methalie in the 8th minute, Enzo Fernández broke the deadlock at the 9th minute with a winning finish. Sunderland's response was immediate: Brian Brobbey equalized at the 12th minute on an assist from Enzo Le Fée, signaling just how contested the afternoon would be. The Black Cats were never willing to back down: Le Bris fielded a team that played with courage and tactical identity, hitting the home side on the counter with technical quality that exceeded expectations.
The first half closed at 3-2 but experienced continuous back-and-forth exchanges. The goal by Rayan Cherki at the 29th minute, assisted by Semenyo, put City ahead; Brobbey made it 2-2 at the 33rd minute on an assist from Meunier, but Antoine Semenyo scored the 3-2 at the 43rd minute with a setup from Marc Guehi, giving Maresca the advantage at halftime. In the second half the script remained frantic: Semenyo struck again at the 57th minute for 4-2, but Brobbey completed a stunning hat-trick at the 59th minute, striking again with a low drive from close range for 4-3. For Sunderland to stay in the match this long at the Etihad is a result that speaks for itself.
To put the final seal on it, Erling Haaland at the 81st minute, assisted by Gvardiol, with VAR confirming the goal at the 83rd minute. The final 5-3 sealed City's overall superiority, though it did not hide the defensive shortcomings that emerged during the match. Donnarumma made four crucial saves, but he was often exposed by a back line that conceded too much to Le Bris's attacks. Brobbey's performance — three goals, ten aerial duels won, five shots — has already entered the club's recent history: he is the first player to score a hat-trick against Manchester City since September 2020, when Vardy prevailed with Leicester.
In the end it was Antoine Semenyo who was the dominant figure of the evening on the City side: two goals and an assist, with three key passes and consistency of performance that confirms him among the absolute protagonists of this Premier League season. Rayan Cherki, in turn, added a goal and two key passes in 85 minutes of crystalline quality. Enzo Fernández provided balance and quality from midfield upward. For Sunderland, despite the defeat, Brobbey's performance and the quantity of chances created suggest that Le Bris's Black Cats are an established reality in English top flight.
#Brobbey and #Semenyo trending on X after the final whistle
Sentiment is divided: City fans celebrate the perfect record but acknowledge defensive problems; Sunderland fans are proud of the team's reaction despite the defeat. Brobbey's hat-trick has captured the attention of the entire English football world.
At the Etihad Stadium on matchday 5 of the Premier League, Manchester City are heavy market favourites (1.29) against a Sunderland side ravaged by injuries and sitting 14th in the table. The Citizens are in superb form with five wins on the spin, while Sunderland struggle to score against the top sides. A City win is the standout pick of the day, with Over 1.5 as an almost automatic companion; the question of whet…
Prediction outcome: for Manchester City-Sunderland the AI analysis picked «1» (confidence 78%); with the final 5-3 the call came good.
Published before kick-off as well: Both teams to score NG at 55%; Over/Under 2.5 Over at 62%; Over/Under 1.5 Over at 88%.
After the final whistle Manchester City are 1st with 12 points from 4 matches (8 scored, 2 conceded), Sunderland 14th on 4 (3 scored, 5 conceded). Manchester City are averaging 3.00 points per game.
| Outcome | Average odds |
|---|---|
| 1 (Manchester City win) | 1.29 |
| X (draw) | 5.44 |
| 2 (Sunderland win) | 9.70 |
| Over 2.5 | 1.58 |
| Under 2.5 | 2.35 |
| Both teams to score | 1.94 |
| No (both teams to score) | 1.80 |
The record of the 6 previous meetings on file: 5 wins for Manchester City, 1 draw and 0 wins for Sunderland. The most recent meeting, on 1 Jan 2026, ended Sunderland 0-0 Manchester City.