Played on Saturday, 5 September 2026, matchday 3 of Serie A, referee A. Colombo.
Match report
Roma-Atalanta 2-1: comeback in the final stages with Hermoso and Soulé, giallorossi go top
By the GoalCast AI editorial team · Published Sunday, 6 September 2026, 02:32 · GoalCast AI
At the Olimpico, one of the most thrilling evenings of the season unfolds. Roma dominates throughout the entire first half, building a continuous siege against an orderly and cautious Atalanta, relying almost exclusively on the saves of an inspired Carnesecchi. Mancini, Cristante, Dybala and Wesley come close to scoring multiple times, but the Bergamo goalkeeper denies everything. 18 shots to 1 in the first half in favor of the giallorossi: a statistic that tells the story of Roma's monologue, yet without finding the back of the net.
The second half opens with a reversed scenario. At 47′ Atalanta takes the lead with Ederson: De Ketelaere reaches the byline and crosses low, the giallorossi defense fails to clear and the Brazilian midfielder strikes hard, beating Svilar. From that moment the Dea comes close to doubling with Samardzic and Krstovic, who miss the target. Roma is down and the law of the goal seemed about to harshly punish the sterile dominance of the first half.
The turning point comes from Gasperini's substitutions: Soulé, Molina and Castro enter, and Roma changes face. The ex-Bologna Castro hits two woodwork — first the post, then the crossbar — while Carnesecchi continues to perform miracles. Dybala, exhausted and suffering from an adductor problem, never stops fighting and stays on the pitch to drive his teammates. The script seemed written for a giallorossi tragedy.
At 90′ Hermoso breaks the spell: the Spanish defender heads home from the corner kick and finds the 1-1. The Olimpico explodes, Roma believes. At 93′ Soulé signs off the comeback: he collects Dybala's through ball, moves inside from the right, beats Zappacosta and finishes Carnesecchi at the near post with a perfect left-footed strike. It's pandemonium. Atalanta feels the blow and also loses Gaetano, sent off for protesting in the final chaos.
A victory built on character, conquered with determination and quality in decisive moments. Three wins out of three for Gasperini's Roma, who go top of the table with a perfect record, tied with Inter. First defeat of the season for Sarri's Atalanta, who must contend with a cursed evening: 9 saves by Carnesecchi were not enough to save the result in the final stages.
Key moments
1°-45′'Complete Roma dominance in the first half: 18 shots against 1 from Atalanta, but Carnesecchi saves everything. Mancini with a header in the 13′, Cristante in the 21′, Dybala and Wesley come close to scoring. First half ends 0-0.
47′'ATALANTA GOAL — Ederson 0-1: De Ketelaere reaches the byline and crosses low, Roma's defense clears poorly, Ederson strikes powerfully and beats Svilar. The visitors take the lead with their first real chance of the second half.
54′'Triple substitution for Roma: Mora and Lulli come off, Soulé and Molina come on. Gasperini transforms his squad seeking greater attacking unpredictability.
~75′-88′'Castro hits post and crossbar, Carnesecchi makes further decisive saves on Dybala and Wesley. The Olimpico holds its breath: the comeback seems impossible.
90′'ROMA GOAL — Hermoso 1-1: the Spanish defender heads home from the corner kick and finds the equalizer. The Olimpico explodes. Roma believes until the end.
90′+3'ROMA GOAL — Soulé 2-1: assist from Dybala, the Argentine cuts inside from the right, beats Zappacosta and finishes Carnesecchi at the near post with a precise left foot. Pandemonium at the Olimpico, comeback complete.
90′+7'Gaetano sent off (Atalanta) for protesting at the end of the match. Nerves shattered for the Bergamo side after the late-game heartbreak.
Player ratings
Man of the match: M. Soulé
AS Roma
M. Svilar 6.5 — Blameless on Ederson, makes necessary saves in the closing stages.
G. Mancini 6 — Dangerous with his head, some uncertainty on the conceded goal.
E. Ndicka 6 — Duels with Scamacca, imprecise in the opposition's goal-scoring move.
P. Dybala 7.5 — 6 key passes, decisive assist for Soulé, soul of the comeback.
Rodrigo Mora 6.5 — Enterprising, seeks vertical solutions before being substituted.
D. Malen 6 — Exploits dribbling but imprecise in front of goal, dull evening.
M. Soulé 9 — 36 minutes as a protagonist: goal, assist and 7 shots. Man of the match.
N. Molina 7 — 5 key passes in 36 minutes, quality in setting up teammates.
D. Ghilardi 6.5 — Enters with confidence, 2 tackles and 4 duels won in 28 minutes.
S. Castro 6.5 — Terrible luck: hits post and crossbar, generous in pressing.
L. Balerdi 6.5 — Important clearances in the final stages, enters with authority.
Atalanta
M. Carnesecchi 8 — 9 extraordinary saves, concedes only in extra time. Epic performance.
R. Bellanova 6 — Suffers Wesley constantly, booked, never convincing.
O. Kossounou 6 — Some slips, saved by the attackers' inaccuracy.
G. Scalvini 6.5 — 6 duels won, 3 tackles, stoic defending despite the loss.
S. Kolašinac 6 — Holds up until substitution, then loses defensive composure.
L. Samardžić 6 — Improves as the match progresses but wastes from close range.
G. Gaetano 5 — Sent off for protesting late on, contributes nothing positive.
Éderson 7 — Powerful and precise goal, the most dangerous of the nerazzurri on the pitch.
C. De Ketelaere 6.5 — 8 duels won, assist for Ederson, the most active in the offensive phase.
G. Scamacca 6 — Duels fiercely but without effectiveness, withdrawn at halftime.
E. Elmas 6 — Almost invisible, contained by Mancini throughout the match.
N. Krstović 5.5 — Wastes the possible 2-0 from a good position, modest performance.
Mario Pasalic 6 — Enters in a complicated phase, fails to change the rhythm.
N. Zalewski 5.5 — Few minutes, almost invisible in the match's narrative.
D. Zappacosta 5.5 — Too soft on Soulé who beats him and scores the winning goal.
F. Kessié 6 — 11 minutes of ordinary administration, insufficient to make an impact.
Social buzz
#DaScudetto and #RomaAtalanta among the evening's trends on X/Twitter
Social media sentiment is dominated by giallorossi fans' euphoria, who after three straight wins openly dream of the title. Mixed/negative tone on the Atalanta side, with frustration over a comeback conceded at the death after a controlled performance.
With this victory Roma go to 9 points in three matches and join Inter at the top of the Serie A table with a perfect record. Atalanta remain on 6 points and slip to seventh place: first defeat of the season for Sarri's men.
What the AI predicted
In the third round of Serie A, a Roma side in superb form hosts an Atalanta coming off three consecutive wins and historically strong in head-to-head clashes at the Olimpico. Roma are favourites thanks to their form and home advantage, but the Dea bring quality and defend well on the road: a hard-fought match with goals at both ends is expected. The main pick is the home win, with coverage on the double chance 1X.
Prediction put to the test: «1», 55% confidence, was the model's call for AS Roma-Atalanta: the 2-1 result confirmed it.
Alongside the 2-1 result in AS Roma-Atalanta, the other calls were: Both teams to score GG at 62%; Over/Under 2.5 Over at 58%; Over/Under 1.5 Over at 85%.
After the final whistle AS Roma are 1st with 9 points from 3 matches (10 scored, 1 conceded), Atalanta 7th on 6 (4 scored, 3 conceded). AS Roma are averaging 3.00 points per game.
The record of the 2 previous meetings on file: 0 wins for AS Roma, 1 draw and 1 win for Atalanta. The most recent meeting, on 18 Apr 2026, ended AS Roma 1-1 Atalanta.