Atalanta 1-2 Cagliari - Serie A

Played on Saturday, 12 September 2026, matchday 4 of Serie A, referee A. Arena.

Match report

Atalanta-Cagliari 1-2: Mendy and Maldini down the Dea at New Balance Arena

Atalanta 1-2 Cagliari: match report card

Cagliari pull off the coup in Bergamo and defeat Maurizio Sarri's Atalanta with a commanding 2-1, signed by Paul Mendy and Daniel Maldini, on matchday four of Serie A. The rossoblu, already solid at the start of the season, confirm themselves as a compact and clinical side, capable of striking on the counter-attack and withstanding the nerazzurri's pressure for over ninety minutes. For Atalanta it is the second consecutive defeat, a warning sign that also weighs on the morale of a group still struggling to find consistency under Sarri's guidance.

The match breaks open in the 19th minute: Michel Adopo advances down the right flank and delivers a low ball to the centre for Paul Mendy, who strikes the ball towards goal from close range — the ball hits the crossbar and bounces in. A goal that has something of a fluke about it for the hosts, and above all curious: it is Mendy's third goal in Serie A, all three scored against Atalanta. The visiting advantage lasts less than twenty-two minutes: at 41' Gianluca Scamacca collects the ball after a rebound between De Ketelaere and Deiola and, with help from a deflection off Obert, beats Caprile for the 1-1 with which the teams head into the dressing rooms.

In the second half Cagliari take control of the game and at the 61st minute find the goal that makes it 2-1: Daniel Maldini, the man who came from the hosts, coolly converts from the spot what turns out to be the first penalty in Serie A 2026/27. Atalanta's defence can no longer reorganise itself and, despite Sarri's substitutions — Krstović, Raspadori and finally Pašalić coming on — the Dea cannot find the equaliser. Late on, tension on the bench leads to the expulsion of a member of Atalanta's coaching staff.

Cagliari's performance was collective and of high standard: Elia Caprile makes three crucial saves and proves to be the best player on the pitch, Winks and Deiola control midfield, while Mendy and Maldini confirm themselves as quality attacking reference points in growing form. Franck Kessié is the most lively among the atalantini — 5 tackles, 3 shots, 8 duels won — but it is not enough to reverse the trend. Rowe, making his debut as a starter in the Dea shirt, shows flashes of technique and determination (10 duels won), without however making a consistent impact in the crucial areas.

Fabio Pisacane's Cagliari have confounded any pre-match predictions: they knew how to alternate defensive solidity and offensive directness, building a victory of the kind that leaves a mark. At the end of the match the rossoblu coach dedicated the success to all the Cagliari people, stressing that the team had remained focused despite the temporary draw. Atalanta on the other hand will have to come to terms with this defeat ahead of their next fixture — the away trip to Juventus — while Cagliari fly to 9 points in the standings, having already collected three victories in four matchdays.

Key moments

Player ratings

Atalanta

Cagliari

Social buzz

#AtalantaCagliari and #Cagliari among Italian trends

Cagliari fans celebrate on social media for the coup in Bergamo, with Caprile and Mendy hailed. Atalanta's fanbase reacts with growing frustration, pointing the finger at defensive solidity and new arrivals yet to be integrated.

With this victory Cagliari rise to 9 points and leapfrog Atalanta in the standings, while the bergamaschi remain stuck on 6 points after four matchdays — a second consecutive defeat that complicates Sarri's path early in the season.

What the AI predicted

In the 4th round of Serie A, Atalanta host a Cagliari side that has surprisingly accumulated 6 points but is now showing signs of a dip in form. The Bergamo side start as clear home favourites, and the head-to-head record points to open, goal-laden affairs. A home win with at least 2 goals in total is the most likely scenario, with Scamacca and De Ketelaere the main attacking references.

Prediction outcome: for Atalanta-Cagliari the AI analysis picked «1» (confidence 62%); with the final 1-2 the call did not come good.

Published before kick-off as well: Both teams to score GG at 58%; Over/Under 2.5 Over at 62%; Over/Under 1.5 Over at 82%.

The table after the match

After the final whistle Atalanta are 8th with 6 points from 3 matches (4 scored, 3 conceded), Cagliari 9th on 6 (2 scored, 1 conceded). Atalanta are averaging 2.00 points per game. The leaders (Lazio, 10 points) are 4 points ahead of Atalanta.

Minute-by-minute

Goalscorers

Line-ups

Atalanta (4-3-3) — coach Maurizio Sarri

Cagliari (4-4-1-1) — coach Fabio Pisacane

Head-to-head record

The record of the 2 previous meetings on file: 1 win for Atalanta, 0 draws and 1 win for Cagliari. The most recent meeting, on 27 Apr 2026, ended Cagliari 3-2 Atalanta.

Previous Atalanta vs Cagliari meetings

Other matches: Matchday 4

Next match

Teams

Competition

The day: Saturday, 12 September 2026

Start free
Today
Competitions
Favorites